20 lakh rupees, but continue to no finish Indian vehicle for me?

Alas, which is not the case and would not appear to be to get any better any time quickly. Until some of you know if a true fantastic contender is coming any time shortly?

New.Beginner not too long ago shared this with other BHPians.


When I acquired my Ford Fiesta Zxi (what the Ford known as Classic afterwards) in 2010, I articulated my joy on the pages of Group-Bhp. They are even now buried some exactly where listed here. In between 2010 and 2021 (oh boy ain’t we glad 2020 is eventually over) that joy only went a person way and I never have to convey to you which way is that.

I would faucet the steering wheel of my motor vehicle twice, as a way of showing my regard, each time I would get to household at odd several hours with my young family in the motor vehicle right after extensive drives. Acknowledging the confidence she has been able to give me, to not consider twice and move all-around irrespective of the time, irrespective of the streets.

But with 11 years beneath its belt, the age begins exhibiting. The actuality that it has taken water when will not aid both. As substantially as I would love to be with her, it is time for me to change. And as a result the massive question..Change TO WHAT?

The Contenders

Everything regarded, a comfortable price range would be 15 lacs. A quick look over the options offered, it does not acquire time to know you will not truly get a lot of Good solutions in that price range. What the heck, this is very first genuine upgrade for me (spouse improved from a M800 to a Maruti Celerio Automated in the necessarily mean whilst) so why not force the envelope a little and the new figure arrived at is Rs. 20 Lacs TOPS.

With that figure in intellect, I started off on the lookout for cars and trucks. The checklist of contenders that I critically thought of went as next:

Kia Seltos

What you get in the vicinity of 12 to 15 lacs leaves you seeking for more. Specifically considering that the car or truck delivers so substantially extra if you in fact cross that rate issue. Took the household to the showroom and we TDed a Petrol Computerized. The motor vehicle has so a great deal to offer you but someway it will not encourage you thoroughly.

Why? It would not automatically offer you more room than what you get in a Fiesta. Boot house, which is a crucial thought for us, is equivalent if not instead somewhat fewer. The structure, which is pleasing appropriate now, may possibly make it appear dated before long plenty of. Difficult to put a finger, but in some way it didn’t sweep us off our ft.

Jeep Compass

Nevertheless I am not an off-roader per say, but I preferred this vehicle from day 1. Watched the launch online video of facelift and that tender corner for the automobile grew even larger. A now fantastic wanting motor vehicle was looking even far better in that movie. Plus, for great or for negative, I somehow like it much better if I am not subsequent the herd. What with absolutely everyone flocking to Kia and Hyundai showrooms these days.

Did a stop by to the only showroom in Gurgaon and even wifey started out to like the car or truck. And this wasn’t even the facelift. The SA did not have the selling price or characteristic record until then but he was able to confirm that the AT starts off from the foundation Activity product in facelift and also realized that the price distinction would be in the vicinity of 1.2 lacs per variant between two styles. We both of those realized that in my funds its only the Sport that suits. Came again with an pretty much certainty that is heading to be a Compass for me.

on 26th January, the SA bought the spec sheet from FCA and he forwarded me that. I wasnt anticipating considerably from the base product but that sheet built me a tiny anxious. Its likely to be a bare bone variant. On the other hand, the price tag was the upcoming issue which I was still waiting around.

On 27th I got the price tag record of new Compass. The sport guide and activity AT has a WHOPPING 2.5 lacs big difference ex-showroom. I could not consider my eyes and called the SA to confirm that the big difference concerning these two is just the Computerized or some “capabilities” are also extra. He verified it is only the transmission. Sport 1.4Mair MT is 16,99,000 and Sport 1.4Mair DDCT is 19,49,000 ex-showroom. As substantially as I tried using, I could not place my head all over having to pay 2.5 lacs a lot more for Automated and Guide is not what I want to buy.

A disappointing get in touch with but experienced to bid goodbye to Compass. Assume of it, properly over 2 Million and you dont even get fog lamps, automated AC, Distant keyless entry, Push Button Start…so a lot so that not even a parcel tray.

Hyundai Creta

Not a lot to produce here. You know why? Because Hyundai dealers are unwilling to entertain you if you are in for Creta. The confront drops and the SA reduce fascination. Tried out two sellers and none of them even experienced a display motor vehicle. Managed to see just one when SA took us to the services place to see if there came one for company. The interaction starts off and finishes in 2 minutes flat which goes anything like..”sir, at least a 6 thirty day period waiting. Could be more. What do I explain to you about the motor vehicle”. Not performed Hyundai.

So conclusion of tale there.

MG Hector

Wasn’t quite hung-ho on this to start off with, but right after a disappointing check out to a Hyundai showroom, considered why not check out out the Hector. Wife and each little ones in the business, we walked into MG flagship showroom in Gurgaon. Most effectively behaved and welcoming staff members welcomed us. The initially thing they did was to give us a walk through of each product on screen in advance of bombarding us with thoughts like “which motor vehicle are you looking for” , “what is your spending plan” , “when do you want to purchase the motor vehicle”, etcetera. which we imagined was the norm at other makes.

I assume in 15 minutes of us coming into the showroom , the little ones were made the decision that it is the Hector that we want. The only problem remained was if it is heading to be Hector Furthermore in 6-seater captain seat avtaar or the Hector 5 seater.

The profits particular person expended more than enough time with us talking both of those automobiles in detail. We did a examination travel of Hector 2021 DCT Sharp. Genuine to the opinions below, it will not excite you but is not a laggard as well. It really is the automobile which seems to be like a SUV but doesn’t push like a single. It would be fair to say, it does not behave otherwise than how my usual town driving model is so was not a authentic downer definitely.

Wife liked the area, the two in the center seat and also at the boot. Kids ended up blown over by all the bells and whistles it has to present. That Tesla fashion central device (they have noticed a large amount of pics of mine savoring that for a quick time I drove Tesla in US), the tremendous great sunroof, the ventilated seats, the voice commands. The record just goes on. The vehicle feels super durable and strongly developed also.

We still left the showroom with a assure that we would decide among Hector Plus 6 seater (it seems awesome in that Sepia Brown interiors as well as the allure of captain seats for kids) or Hector 5 seater which was a extra practical option for us. Both autos in Sharp variant would exceed 2 million mark on road by 50 grand and 150 grand respectively.

What followed was my in depth lookup online and offline on what could be erroneous with Hector. I am not heading to get into Chinese pedigree, the danger of them leaving the state and many others. But what was just one of the major put off was the noted FE of 6 to 7 for Hector AT. I, or for that matter any person can, stretch their spending budget a person time to invest in the motor vehicle they like. But the moment that joy of new automobile is more than, the discomfort of emptying your pockets each individual time you get a tank complete (which you would do a good deal additional given the FE) will make you disappointed or offended or felt cheated or all of them in the more time run.

That remaining a key thing to consider , there goes the Hector much too. Or so I assume.

Tata Harrier

In will come the most beloved auto from Tata stable. Style sensible, its a individual selection among Hector and Harrier. Suffice to say the two have a enthusiast subsequent. The room is slightly far more in Hector (more substantial boot etc.) . The explanation I wasn’t actively pursuing this car was the niggling challenges I maintain on looking at on this and other boards. Even so, I am also knowledgeable that just like XUV500, the auto will keep on improving upon and the later you purchase the much better healthy and finish it would be minus the niggles (with any luck ,).

I was reading through for several months that Tata may release Gravitas (eventually Safari) with their newly produced Petrol motor and when that transpires the very same alternative could be obtainable for Harrier way too. Alas, the Safari introduced with out the petrol variant so I you should not see any around potential chance of a Harrier with a petrol motor.

I termed Tata showroom and asked for for a TD at my place. The SA came with the auto (it was XZA Dim Version automobile) and we test drove it. The automobile has similar cabin house to present as the Hector albeit with a significantly smaller boot. This currently being a greater potential Diesel power dwelling, does surely drives extra spiritedly than the Hector Petrol AT. Of system, returns a significantly improved gasoline effectiveness also.

Between the Hector and the Harrier, has to be mentioned Harrier is far better outfitted in the initial row and the dashboard. Not that Harrier is ugly or terrible, its just not up there. Take that odd on the lookout hand brake for illustration. Base line, not much to not like but not too considerably to wow far too.

The leading line expense me 23 lacs some thing and the future finest (XZA) charge me about 21 lacs. What I overlook out on is the sunroof (youngsters enjoy it and for me its very good if its there. If not, am not gonna skip it), electrical adjusted driver seat and points like that.

I can are living with the prime but just one variant in a increased cost than the leading variant Hector, but and a major BUT is its a diesel. I am not the one who changes autos very normally. I drove a middle 2000 engineering car or truck for 11 many years. I am certain a late 20’s technology vehicle would past / should really final substantially lengthier. But becoming in NCR, I would have no alternative but to switch it in 10 a long time max. 10 several years from now is a lengthy time. Although I surely do not know what or how it could be, but I know for a simple fact that I would be needing a large amount of dollars for other matters. Would I be inclined to just take a huge chunk out of it to invest on one more motor vehicle? Of study course it would be unachievable to settle for a smaller hatch back at the time you get applied to a dimensions. Bottom line, I am not incredibly absolutely sure if I want a Diesel.

Honda City

In will come Honda Town. To think of it there is not even yet another automobile obtainable anymore. I would have cherished to enhance to a “superior” sedan if there was a decision. I in point began my look for wanting for just one. My person opinion is, if I want a SUV, I will buy a SUV. All the things else shown over is pseudo. Even so, no SUV is offered unless of course your budget is 30 lacs (conservatively ) and close to 40 if you require a absolutely loaded. I of course do not have a spending budget like that.

Coming back again to Sedans. You have Town, Verna, Immediate, Civic (around priced for what it provides more than metropolis?) or Elantra and Vento (dated). And which is just about it.

Verna was rejected by spouse within a pair of minutes of us becoming in the exhibit space. The auto will not have significantly heading its way from dimension to storage room to seems (own choice) and so forth. Town on the other hand is a difficult vehicle to say no to. The at any time recognized assurance of top quality, the cult pursuing, wonderfully intended, very best boot area, Security (e.g. 6 airbags on top rated variant), a great AT, costing a great 5 lacs fewer than Hectors and Harriers of the environment.

BUT, the experience that you get is that you are shifting absent from a automobile that has gotten previous to a new automobile. There is no perception of course update. It plays on your brain that the car you are purchasing has been about for 20+ decades (facelifts aside) and most importantly, and rely on me it does, feels like you are forced to purchase this motor vehicle since there are no solutions available and not mainly because you liked this the most effective among all some others.


If you have arrive hence far, I can not thank you ample. I know it has been a very long post. But if you have, I am confident you concur with the idea that I have designed that if you are out in the marketplace with a 2 Million budget, you dont get a auto which ticks all the boxes. Harrier doesnt have petrol and Hector doesnt have Diesel computerized for case in point. A person car or truck offers you a great deal of characteristics but is either new or lacks on other things the other car or truck just merely feels above priced (circumstance in level Harrier or Compass).

Many thanks to New.Novice the moment once more! Check out out BHPian remarks for additional insights & data.

Consequently, whilst I am still undecided which just one it is going to be, I imagined I will initiate this discussion right here and pick on the thoughts of far more “tuned” people. How I would like we have preference of qualified sedans between 15 to 20 lacs, I would have not even thought of a crossover and would have waited for my finances to fulfill the threshold of a genuine blue SUV. Alas, that is not the situation and will not appear to get any superior any time before long. Unless of course some of you know if a actual excellent contender is coming any time shortly?

Many thanks to New.Beginner when yet again! Test out BHPian reviews for additional insights & info.